Gathering Dust
Jun. 3rd, 2004 10:03 amI'd been meaning to reread and tinker with "Sealed With A Curse" since it bounced back from SCIFICTION, but every time I pulled it out, my stomach did a major sink to my toes and my brain screamed, "Noooooo!"
I've done a lot of tinkering with that story. Originally (about three years ago), it was around 20k. I whittled that down to 17.5 before posting it to OWW. That version got an Editor's Choice, but in Kelly Link's review she said there was a lot of fat in the languageāand she was right. She also suggested adding three scenes she thought the story needed. Ironically, I'd cut two of those scenes before posting it. I added them back in, wrote the third because I thought she was right there, too, and clarified character issues. I cut a ton of fat and wasted language. Even with the added scenes, I managed to bring SWAC down to 15.5k before sending it out in October. Got the rejection from SCIFICTION in November.
I thought I could probably cut another 500 words by smooshing two scenes together but it wasn't immediately apparent to me how I could do that and still maintain the integrity of the story, so I decided to let it go fallow for a bit while my subconscious worked on the problem and I worked on other projects. I picked the story up again the first part of this year and that's when I noticed the mind screaming-stomach dropping thing for the first time. "Okay," I says, "I guess I'm not ready to work on this yet."
The pattern has continued for months now. I'm not sure if the resistance is because I'm just sick, sick, sick of this story, or if my subconscious thinks it's a mistake to slash it further, or whatever. Whatever, the story's just been gathering dust. I think the chances of selling such a behemoth are pretty slim, but if it's sitting in a drawer the chances are exactly zero. So since my mind/stomach refuses to take the jump, I'll have to bypass that jump and go on to the next.
I sent the story out yesterday to F&SF. I expect my rejection by Monday at the latest. It almost certainly won't grab Joe Adams, and if it doesn't grab Joe, there's no chance of an "alas" from Gordon (yeah, I got the who-does-the-alasing bit wrong). I'm convinced I'll never write a story that grabs Joe, although once I did fail to hold his attention, and one other time I didn't work for him. So sending it to F&SF is a way of checking another tick off my marketing list, but not something I ever seriously consider as a possibility.
Sure would be cool if I was wrong, though.
I've done a lot of tinkering with that story. Originally (about three years ago), it was around 20k. I whittled that down to 17.5 before posting it to OWW. That version got an Editor's Choice, but in Kelly Link's review she said there was a lot of fat in the languageāand she was right. She also suggested adding three scenes she thought the story needed. Ironically, I'd cut two of those scenes before posting it. I added them back in, wrote the third because I thought she was right there, too, and clarified character issues. I cut a ton of fat and wasted language. Even with the added scenes, I managed to bring SWAC down to 15.5k before sending it out in October. Got the rejection from SCIFICTION in November.
I thought I could probably cut another 500 words by smooshing two scenes together but it wasn't immediately apparent to me how I could do that and still maintain the integrity of the story, so I decided to let it go fallow for a bit while my subconscious worked on the problem and I worked on other projects. I picked the story up again the first part of this year and that's when I noticed the mind screaming-stomach dropping thing for the first time. "Okay," I says, "I guess I'm not ready to work on this yet."
The pattern has continued for months now. I'm not sure if the resistance is because I'm just sick, sick, sick of this story, or if my subconscious thinks it's a mistake to slash it further, or whatever. Whatever, the story's just been gathering dust. I think the chances of selling such a behemoth are pretty slim, but if it's sitting in a drawer the chances are exactly zero. So since my mind/stomach refuses to take the jump, I'll have to bypass that jump and go on to the next.
I sent the story out yesterday to F&SF. I expect my rejection by Monday at the latest. It almost certainly won't grab Joe Adams, and if it doesn't grab Joe, there's no chance of an "alas" from Gordon (yeah, I got the who-does-the-alasing bit wrong). I'm convinced I'll never write a story that grabs Joe, although once I did fail to hold his attention, and one other time I didn't work for him. So sending it to F&SF is a way of checking another tick off my marketing list, but not something I ever seriously consider as a possibility.
Sure would be cool if I was wrong, though.